Why plain text beats a black box for agent memory

And the cases where it doesn't. The aim is to help you pick the right tool, not to win an argument.

The problem isn't remembering, it's trusting what was remembered

Give an agent a memory and it will, sooner or later, remember something wrong: a decision that was reversed, a preference that was only true last month, a "fact" it inferred and never confirmed. With a conventional memory layer you usually find out by watching the agent behave strangely, then trying to work out which stored fragment is responsible.

The things you want when that happens are the same things you want for code: to see the current state, to see what changed and when, to fix one thing without disturbing the rest, and to undo. Source control already solves all four, for text.

What you get from plain text

What it costs

When you should pick something else

The sweet spot

A coding agent working on a project over weeks. A personal assistant that should know your preferences. A research agent accumulating notes. In each, the memory is small enough to hold in your head and valuable enough that you want to know what's in it.